Amalek Revisited

Amalek Revisited
Amalekites like Fuentes should never be ignored or dismissed. They must be confronted directly.

Over six years ago, I penned an early entry in my “Z’khor Y’mot Olam” series on Jewish historiography, focusing on the Amalek archetype and its expression in modern times.

Less than a year after the “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville, nobody knew that Nick Fuentes – a recent college dropout with a YouTube livestream show called “America First” – would become one of the most recognizable voices on the American right. But today, we can confidently say that he has become one of our generation’s most articulate expressions of Amalek.

As Jews this passed Shabbat were hearing Parshat Toldot, featuring the birth of our ancestor Yaakov and his twin brother Esav, the New Christian Right (NXR) met in Dallas for a conference titled “[Yoshke] is King – America After Trump.”

Fuentes was featured at the conference as the surprise special guest, delivering the keynote address and participating in a final panel with Joel Webbon, the event’s chief organizer. 

The NXR sees itself as the vanguard of Western civilization, its most ideologically motivated cohort that holds the key to preventing civilizational decline and restoring the Christian West to its former greatness. And Fuentes has become the most popular face and voice of the movement, with his once unknown show consistently reaching over a million views – despite being relegated to alternative platforms like Rumble.

The way Fuentes tells his own story of “noticing” and becoming critical of what he refers to as “Israel First” interests in US politics bears a striking resonance with Amalek’s own midrashic origin story. Our sages teach us that Amalek’s mother, Timna, was impressed by the upright character of our ancestors, and felt driven to attach herself to Israel’s formation. But after being rejected, she settled for living as a concubine to Elifaz, the son of Esav.

Our sages justify Amalek’s enmity towards Israel with the claim, “they should not have pushed her away.”

Fuentes recalls that, as a high schooler and college freshman, he was drawn towards mainstream conservative politics, like that expressed by the Daily Wire and Ben Shapiro.

Kassy Dillon, a fellow conservative student in the Boston area who worked for the Daily Wire, initially sought to connect Fuentes with Shapiro, but quickly distanced herself once Ben attacked Nick on Twitter for a post about loyalty to the United States, accusing him of anti-Semitism.

Kassy has since joined the Jewish people, while Nick has become one of the most influential critics of Israel on the American right. 

The historical echo of Timna’s rejection in how Fuentes sees himself is only the tip of the iceberg when it comes to his identification with Amalek.

One of the sharpest distinctions between the particular identity of Amalek and the broader camp of Edom is that, while Edom has historically and midrashically judged itself in relation to other great empires – Greece, Persia, Babylon, and their successors throughout the generations – Amalek has always been laser-focused on one struggle, the struggle against Israel.

So at the NXR conference, where Fuentes doubled down on his position that Trump has lost his coalition for supporting an Israeli war against Iran, it should be clear that he was arguing that anyone who sees Iran as a greater threat to US interests than Israel cannot be considered “America First.” 

In this same vein, he argued that the only way to retake the country from the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), who he sees as agents of a “Jewish agenda” to weaken Western Civilization, is to install an “America First” candidate able to challenge the “controlled opposition” within the Republican party. Of course, this “controlled opposition” includes Palantir (a tech company that holds a strategic partnership with the Israeli ministry of defense), NatCon (a loose network of Western nationalists who see Israel as an inspiration for “Biblical nationalism,” led by Israeli-American academic Yoram Hazony), and Vice President JD Vance.

It should be noted that Fuentes’s consistent of critique of Jews and Israel is simply a restatement of the Amalekite Haman’s warning to Aḥashverosh.

“There is a ascertain people scattered abroad and dispersed among the people in all the provinces of your kingdom, and their laws are different from all peoples and they do not keep the king’s laws.”

Fuentes recently said in a livestream, “Israel is unlike every other country in the sense that because the Jewish people are in a diaspora all over the world, there are significant numbers of Jews in Europe, but also in the United States. And because of their unique heritage and story, which is that they’re a stateless people, they’re unassimilable, they resist assimilation for thousands of years.”

The parallel is chilling.

Most important for us, if Fuentes can be identified as today’s Amalek, then our mission is clear. If we are to advance the next chapter of Jewish history, we must directly engage with and defeat the ideology he represents.

Attempting to censor or dismiss figures like Fuentes, while ignoring him and appealing to the liberal center won’t work. Every attempt to follow this paths over the last decade has only emboldened him and his following.

We can choose to play an active role in the war of Amalek – something the Rambam characterizes as one of Israel’s final collective projects before restoring Jerusalem to its full glory – if we take the time to internalize the sparks of truth in Fuentes’s critiques and defang them through our own national growth and development.

Support Vision on Patreon Donate to Vision via PayPal
More from Aryeh Leib Shapiro
Z’khor Y’mot Olam – Remember the Days of Old
The idea of history as a cyclical - rather than linear -...
Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.