Nationalism, Internationalism, the State & the Torah

Nationalism, Internationalism, the State & Torah Study
The shallow political conversation surrounding the Ḥaredi draft question exposes a shallow understanding of the State of Israel & its purpose.

History is a graveyard of national identities who’ve gone extinct. Many of them had great polities and armies but to no avail.

Yet the Jewish people, who existed for two millennia in a stateless and defenseless form, endured.

The Jews are evidence that a people can survive conquest, dispersion, exile, persecution, and even genocide, so long that they hold strong against the forces of cultural illiteracy, apathy, and neglect.

In the struggle for Jewish national survival, our greatest asset is not our economy, our army, or even our state. It is our Torah.

The counterfactual of exilic survival raises a deeper question: if the greatest asset in Jewish national survival has been our Torah, why do we need a state at all? Is the State of Israel truly defensible not just as a post hoc appeal to inertia but as a positive objective ab initio?

Some Jews argue that the state is necessary not just for our survival but for the economic and cultural welfare of our people. But this justification is equally unsatisfying.

The Jewish people developed no cultural deficiency in exile. We enjoyed a wide range of social and political movements (including Zionism), great works of art, music, incredible poetry, groundbreaking works of stage and screen, concept-breaking scientific developments, and an unrivaled library of celebrated literature.

The State of Israel actually appears to have done little to guarantee the economic wellbeing of Jews; the household income of Israelis ($42,000/year household median) still lags well behind that of their Jewish counterparts in the United States ($129,000/year).

The objective of the Jewish state, therefore, cannot be cultural or economic welfare any more than it can be national survival, as all these things appear to have been delivered in its absence.

So why have a state at all?

It cannot be the case that the State of Israel exists primarily for the benefit of the Jewish people, as all purported benefits (survival, cultural and economic welfare, etc.) exist independent of statehood.

The Jewish state must exist for the benefit of the entire world.

The State of Israel does not primarily exist to make a positive change for the Jewish people, but to affect a positive change on the global stage. For this task, there is no alternative to statehood. As HaRav Avraham Yitzḥak HaKohen Kook writes, “the State of Israel is HaShem’s throne in the world, whose entire desire is that HaShem should be One and His Name should be one.” (Orot Yisrael 6:7)

Those who seek to justify the state’s existence as a nationalist project, in terms of its narrow benefit to the Jewish people alone, will come away unsatisfied. Those who instead conceptualize the necessity of the state as part of an internationalist endeavor, an effort to create a social and political model of justice and harmony from which the entire world can learn, emulate, and improve themselves, will discover a limitless wellspring of conviction.

Recognizing the necessity of the Jewish state as the basis of an internationalist project to diffuse social justice by presenting a workable social model in the wisdom of Torah is an acknowledgement of the awesome importance of both military service and Torah study.

Israeli political discourse, however, remains trapped in a limited nationalist framework that evaluates Torah study and military service primarily by their contribution to Jewish survival: the proposed coalition combining Liberal Zionist partiess and Ḥaredi factions is a testament to this misfortune.

A state and the work required to facilitate it is necessary, not as a nationalist project for survival, wealth, or development, but as an internationalist endeavor for the benefit of the entire world.

The failure to internalize and articulate this concept has resulted in an unnecessary divide within the Jewish people and a deterioration of conversation on important issues.

Support Vision on Patreon Donate to Vision via PayPal
Written By
More from Yishai Edberg
The Trotskyist Roots of Yoram Hazony’s ‘National Conservatism’
How messianic desire & diasporic aversion to power created a globally dominant...
Read More

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.